Mittens vs. Gloves

When the air turns cold you reach for gloves or mittens, and the choice between them is an old argument. The short version is that mittens are warmer and gloves let you use your fingers.

NIOSH, part of the CDC, says to wear several layers of loose clothing, to avoid tight clothing because it reduces circulation to the extremities, and to protect your hands in extremely cold weather.[1] This guide compares the two designs and six pairs, three mittens and three gloves.

This article is general information, not medical advice. See a doctor if your fingers stay numb, white or painful after warming up.

Gloves vs mittens at a glance

  • The American Academy of Pediatrics says mittens are warmer than gloves, and that tight gloves can interfere with circulation.[2]
  • NIOSH says tight clothing reduces blood circulation, and warm blood needs to circulate to the extremities.[1]
  • The AAP says to change wet gloves right away, because frostbite is worse when skin and clothing are wet.[2]
  • NIOSH says to carry spare gloves and to avoid touching cold metal with bare skin.[1]
  • Three of the six picks are mittens and three are gloves, and four of them work on a touchscreen.


Glove vs. Mitten

  • Mittens – A mitten has one pocket for all four fingers and a separate thumb. Your fingers share heat, so a mitten is warmer than a glove of the same material, but you give up finger movement.
  • Gloves – A glove wraps each finger on its own, which gives you grip, dexterity and flexibility. Separated fingers lose more heat, so a glove is cooler than a mitten.

Keeping your hands dry matters as much as the design. A wet glove or mitten pulls heat away, so you want a shell that keeps water out and a lining that does not trap sweat.[2] For extreme cold, choose a mitten. When you need your fingers, choose a glove.


Features of a Good Glove


  • Lining – A fleece or insulated lining keeps heat in.
  • Water Resistance – A water-repelling outer material keeps your hands dry.[2]
  • Dexterity – The glove should let you use your fingers, even when padded.
  • Breathability – The glove should wick moisture and keep sweat from building up inside.
  • Fit – Snug is fine, but a tight glove restricts circulation.[2]

Features of a Good Mitten

  • Shell – The outer shell should be durable, light and resistant to water and abrasion.
  • Interior – Fleece or insulation such as Thinsulate gives warmth.
  • Stitching – Solid stitching and a reinforced palm last longer.
  • Hand Warmer Pocket – Some mittens add a pocket for hand warmers.

How We Chose These Gloves and Mittens

These picks come from research. This is desk research. We compared the manufacturer specifications and product descriptions for each pick. We did not test the gloves ourselves, and we did not check stock this time.

We looked at these factors:

  • Warmth – Lining, insulation and the glove or mitten design.
  • Weather – Waterproof or water-resistant shells.
  • Use – Touchscreen fingertips, grip and dexterity.
  • Fit – Sizing, cuffs and thumb design.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Gloves and Mittens


  1. Are mittens warmer than gloves?
    Yes. Mittens keep your fingers together so they share heat, and the AAP says mittens are warmer than gloves.[2]

  2. Which should I choose for extreme cold?
    A mitten. A glove is the better choice when you need to grip a tool, use a phone or work with your fingers.

  3. Should gloves be tight?
    No. NIOSH says tight clothing reduces circulation to the extremities, and the AAP says tight gloves can interfere with circulation.[1][2]

  4. How do I keep my hands from getting cold?
    Keep them dry. Change wet gloves or socks right away and carry a spare pair.[1][2]

  5. What are the signs of frostbite?
    Cold, tingling and painful skin is mild frostbite or frostnip. White, hard, numb skin is frostbite and needs medical care after rewarming.[2]


Our Picks: Gloves and Mittens

Here are 6 gloves and mittens, from waterproof mitts to touchscreen gloves.
We hope you love the gloves and mittens we recommend!
So that you know, we may earn a share of sales or other compensation from links on this page. This does not change your price.


1

Outdoor Research® Unisex Meteor Waterproof Insulated Mitts

Currently unavailable

The Outdoor Research Meteor is a waterproof and windproof mitt for indoor and outdoor winter use.
  • It has a nylon lining and an easy pull-on closure with a snug fit.
  • You can machine wash it.
  • As a mitt, it keeps your fingers together for warmth and gives up finger movement.


2

Smartwool® Unisex Cozy Merino Wool Mittens

Currently unavailable

The Smartwool Cozy is a mitten made of 48% Merino wool with a warm interior lining.
  • The terry loop interior adds warmth and cushioning.
  • The fabric works on touchscreens, so you can use a phone without taking the mitten off.


3

Northstar® Unisex Deerskin Fur-Lined Deerskin Winter Mittens

Currently unavailable

The Northstar is a chopper-style mitten with deerskin leather uppers and a Sherpa lining.
  • The lined winged thumb is cut for a more comfortable fit.
  • Leather uppers are durable for outdoor work, and the Sherpa lining insulates.


4

The North Face® Unisex Etip Touchscreen Warm Gloves

Currently unavailable

The North Face Etip is a fleece and polyester winter glove with touchscreen-compatible fingertips.
  • The palm has a grip pattern.
  • It is made for casual wear in cold weather, not for heavy work or deep cold.


5

Winter CC® Unisex Quad Acrylic Wool Touchscreen Gloves

Currently unavailable

The Winter CC Quad is an acrylic wool glove with touchscreen fingertips, sold in many colors.
  • The palm and fingers are reinforced for grip.
  • The size runs small, so it suits women and teenagers best.


6

Heritage® Unisex Winter Leather Outdoor Trail Gloves

Currently unavailable

The Heritage is a leather glove with a thick polar fleece liner for hiking and trail walking.
  • An elastic cuff band holds the glove in place.
  • Outseam construction on the fingers gives a more comfortable fit.


Index Table: Top Rated Gloves and Mittens

No.ProductImageFeaturesBrandScore
1Outdoor Research Unisex Meteor - Waterproof Insulated Mitts
Outdoor Research Meteor Mitts, Black/Charcoal, L
  • Waterproof
  • Windproof
  • Nylon Lined
  • Machine Washable
Outdoor Research-
2Smartwool Unisex Cozy - Merino Wool Mittens
Smartwool Cozy Mitten - Black Small/Medium
  • 48% Merino Wool
  • Warm Lining
  • Terry Loop Interior
  • Touchscreen Compatible
Smartwool-
3Northstar Unisex Deerskin - Fur-Lined Deerskin Winter Mittens
Northstar Unisex Full Grain Deerskin Sherpa Lined Mitten, Tan, Full Fingered 51T
  • Deerskin Leather
  • Sherpa Lined
  • Winged Thumb
  • Chopper Style
Northstar-
4The North Face Unisex Etip - Touchscreen Warm Gloves
The North Face Etip Glove, TNF Black, Large
  • Fleece and Polyester
  • Touchscreen Fingertips
  • Good Grip
  • Casual Wear
The North Face-
5Winter CC Unisex Quad - Acrylic Wool Touchscreen Gloves
Winter CC Quad Touch Screen Smart Cellphone Finger Tips Warm Soft Gloves (Leopard New Olive)
  • Acrylic Wool
  • Touchscreen Compatible
  • Reinforced Palm and Fingers
  • Many Colors
Winter CC-
6Heritage Unisex Winter - Leather Outdoor Trail Gloves
Heritage Winter Trail Gloves, Size 9, Black
  • Leather
  • Polar Fleece Liner
  • Elastic Cuff
  • Outseam Construction
Heritage-

Sources

  1. CDC, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). Cold Stress. Accessed October 27, 2026.
  2. HealthyChildren.org (American Academy of Pediatrics). Frostbite. Accessed October 27, 2026.

Update History

  • Oct 2026: Rewrote the article around NIOSH cold stress and American Academy of Pediatrics frostbite guidance, removed the unsupported expert opinion claims and the old score tables, added a short health disclaimer, fixed names in the product notes, rewrote all product notes and added Sources
  • Jun 2020: Published


About the Author

John Max

John is a certified fitness trainer, writer, and health enthusiast and has worked with people of all age groups. He understands the difference a right pair of gloves makes towards your health and comfort. He reads a lot of stuff on the internet to explore and stay updated with the latest advancements in the gloves industry. John also regularly tests and analyzes the benefits and features of as many gloves as possible. Without a surprise, many of our readers love his reviews and testing style for how thorough and straightforward they are.